Universal life insurance, with its two main product lines – Variable Universal Life (VUL) and Indexed Universal Life (IUL) – is becoming popular due to its flexibility and financial potential. This article provides a detailed analysis of these two types of universal life insurance, helping you understand their operating mechanisms, advantages and disadvantages, and how to select the most suitable product.
What is Universal Life Insurance?
Universal Life Insurance is a type of permanent life insurance that combines protection and investment elements. Unlike traditional whole life insurance, universal life insurance allows policyholders to adjust their premium payments and death benefit amounts while also providing an opportunity for account value growth through investments.
Features of Universal Life Insurance
In the United States, universal life insurance complies with strict legal regulations, notably Section 7702 of the Tax Code. This ensures that the product maintains its insurance characteristics while offering significant tax benefits:
- Tax-Free Death Benefit: The death benefit is not subject to income tax.
- Tax-Deferred Growth: The account value grows tax-deferred.
- Tax-Free Access to Cash: Policy loans allow tax-free access to cash value as long as the policy remains in force.
For Vietnamese individuals in the U.S., these features create an effective financial tool for:
- Protecting the family
- Supplementing retirement savings
- Transferring wealth across generations
- Legally optimizing tax obligations
Mechanism of Universal Life Insurance
Customer premium payments are allocated as follows:
- Risk Insurance Cost: The portion used to cover the death benefit.
- Contract and Fund Management Fees: These are the costs for operating and managing the account.
Investment in the Accumulation Account: The remaining amount is credited to the cash value account.
This mechanism allows participants to adjust their premium levels flexibly (within certain limits) based on their financial capabilities, as long as the account maintains sufficient value to cover both the risk insurance cost and the management fees.
What is VUL (Variable Universal Life) Insurance?
VUL is a type of universal life insurance that allows the policyholder to invest the account value into various investment funds (sub-accounts), similar to mutual funds. Due to its investment nature, VUL is regulated by both the insurance authority and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
Advantages of VUL
- Unlimited Growth Potential: When the market rises, the account value can increase significantly without an upper limit.
- Diverse Investment Choices: Options include equity funds, bonds, money markets, and real estate.
- Investment Control: Policyholders have the power to decide on asset allocation.
- Comprehensive Tax Benefits: Tax-free growth, tax-free access to cash, and a tax-free death benefit.
Notable VUL Programs
Transamerica Financial Foundation VUL®
- Offers a wide range of investment options with over 60 different funds
- Provides a minimum interest guarantee for the fixed deposit portion
- Features an Overloan Protection Rider to safeguard the policy from excessive borrowing
AIG’s AG Platinum Choice VUL
- Provides a diverse range of indices and investment funds
- Offers unlimited switching between funds
- Ensures a guaranteed death benefit with appropriate riders
Allianz Life Pro+® VUL
- Combines the features of VUL with those of permanent life insurance
- Offers diverse investment options managed professionally
- Protects against market volatility with secure investment options
What is IUL (Indexed Universal Life) Insurance?
IUL is a type of universal life insurance that ties returns to the performance of market indices such as the S&P 500, Nasdaq Composite, or Russell 2000. A key feature of IUL is its 0% interest floor to protect the policyholder from losses when the market declines, along with a cap rate (typically between 8-14%) that limits the gains when the market surges.
Advantages of IUL:
- Capital Protection: Ensures that the account value does not go negative when the market falls.
- Market-Linked Growth: Benefits from the growth of market indices.
- Long-Term Stability: Generally experiences less volatility compared to VUL, making it suitable for those with a moderate risk appetite.
- Greater Transparency: Interest crediting is based on a clearly defined formula.
See also:
Comparison of VUL and IUL
Comparison of Operating Mechanisms
| Criteria | VUL | IUL |
| Investment Mechanism | Direct investment in various funds | Tracks the performance of market indices |
| Risk | Higher, with potential for capital loss | Lower, with a protective floor |
| Profit Potential | Unlimited | Limited by a cap rate |
| Management Fees | Generally higher | Generally lower |
| Complexity | More complex, requires investment knowledge | Simpler, less intensive monitoring |
Comparison of Insurance Benefits
Both VUL and IUL provide basic insurance benefits such as a death benefit, but there are differences in additional options:
- Critical Illness Benefit: Both types include this benefit; however, IUL often comes with free Accelerated Death Benefit Riders.
- Long-Term Care: Many IUL products have this feature built-in.
Income Protection in Case of Disability: VUL generally offers more diverse options.
Comparison of Investment Performance
The performance of VUL and IUL depends on market conditions:
- Strong Market Growth: VUL usually outperforms due to the absence of a cap.
- Sideways or Volatile Markets: IUL typically delivers more stable results.
- Market Downturns: IUL better protects the capital with its interest floor.
Based on data from 2000 to 2020, which includes two major crises (in 2001 and 2008), IUL yielded an average annual return of approximately 6-8%, while VUL ranged from -5% to +12% depending on the investment strategy.
Comparison of Cash Access Features
Both VUL and IUL allow policyholders to borrow from the cash value of the policy. However:
- VUL: Loan interest rates are often tied to market performance and can fluctuate.
- IUL: Loan interest rates tend to be fixed or index-based, making them more predictable.
The ability to withdraw funds without affecting the policy’s tax status is an important benefit of both products.
Tax Benefits of VUL and IUL
One of the reasons universal life insurance is popular among the Vietnamese community in the U.S. is the significant tax advantages:
- Tax-Deferred Growth: The cash value in the policy grows without annual taxation, maximizing compounding benefits.
- Tax-Free Access to Cash Value: Through policy loans, policyholders can access cash without incurring income tax, provided the policy remains in force.
- Tax-Free Death Benefit: Beneficiaries receive the death benefit tax-free under federal law.
- Exemption from NIIT (Net Investment Income Tax): Insurance proceeds are not subject to the 3.8% tax on net investment income imposed by Obamacare.
- Supplementation of Other Retirement Plans: VUL and IUL can effectively complement 401(k), IRA, and other retirement plans, especially after maxing out contributions to these accounts.
Who Should Choose VUL, and Who Should Choose IUL?
For New Immigrants
VUL is Suitable for:
- Those with strong investment knowledge
- Individuals with a high risk tolerance
- People with stable and surplus income
- Those who wish to actively manage their investments
IUL is Suitable for:
- Individuals are beginning to build their financial foundation in the U.S.
- Those who prioritize capital preservation
- People looking for a simple approach to financial management
- Individuals seeking a stable, less volatile plan
For Those Who Are Financially Established
For Vietnamese who are well-established in the U.S., choosing between VUL and IUL depends on:
- Financial Goals: Maximizing accumulation vs. preserving assets
- Investment Time Horizon: Long-term vs. medium-term expectations
- Risk Appetite: Willingness to accept volatility for potentially higher returns
Tax Situation: Those in higher tax brackets might benefit more
Experience in Purchasing Universal Life Insurance
Medical Underwriting Process
When purchasing insurance in the U.S., the medical underwriting process tends to be more stringent than in Vietnam:
- Medical Examinations: Blood tests, urine tests, and sometimes even X-rays
- Information Verification: Review of medical records, prescriptions, and family medical history
- Non-Medical Underwriting: Examination of driving records, credit history, and occupation
- Advice: Prepare a complete and truthful medical history when declaring your health information.
See also:
Understanding the Contract Illustration
Insurance contract illustrations are often lengthy and complex. Key points to note include:
- Guaranteed vs. Non-Guaranteed Values: Distinguishing between guaranteed and non-guaranteed amounts
- Cost of Insurance: The cost of risk insurance may increase with age
- Surrender Charges: Early termination fees that typically decrease over time
- Illustration Rates: The illustrated rate may not reflect actual future performance
Evaluating the Insurer’s Financial Strength
Before signing a contract, assess the insurer’s financial strength by:
- Ratings from A.M. Best, Moody’s, and S&P: Choose companies with an A rating or higher
- Operational History: Prefer insurers with a long and stable track record
- Claims-Payment Ability: Look at the claim payout ratios and overall financial stability
Conclusion
Both VUL and IUL universal life insurance are powerful financial tools for Vietnamese in the U.S., combining family protection, wealth accumulation, and tax optimization. The choice between the two depends on:
- VUL: Suitable for those with investment expertise, a high risk tolerance, and a desire to maximize potential returns.
- IUL: Ideal for individuals who prioritize stability, capital preservation, and steady growth.
Companies such as National Life Group, AIG, Allianz, and Transamerica offer quality products with unique features. Prospective buyers should seek advice from financial experts familiar with both the U.S. financial system and the specific needs of the Vietnamese community to make the best-informed decision.
Additionally, you can contact the hotline at (678) 722 3447 or send a message via Messenger and email Support@Thinksmartinsurance.com to receive a consultation from Thinksmart Insurance’s team regarding a program that fits your financial condition and to get a free quote.
FAQs
1. Can non-U.S. citizens purchase universal life insurance?
Yes, non-U.S. citizens with legal residency (such as Green Card holders, H1B, L1 visa holders, etc.) can purchase insurance. However, some restrictions may apply, such as:
- A lower maximum face amount
- Minimum residency requirements in the U.S.
- The need for an SSN or ITIN
- A more rigorous underwriting process
2. How can one avoid MEC (Modified Endowment Contract) when purchasing insurance in the U.S.?
MEC refers to a policy that violates the 7-pay test, causing it to lose its tax advantages. To avoid this:
- Do not pay premiums exceeding the 7-pay test limit
- Exercise caution when increasing the face amount
- Consult a financial expert before making significant adjustments to premium payments
- Monitor notifications from the insurer regarding MEC risks
3. If I move back to Vietnam, will my U.S. insurance policy remain in force?
Most U.S. insurance policies remain valid when you relocate to Vietnam, but keep in mind the following:
- Inform the insurer about any change of address
- Maintain a U.S. bank account for premium payments
- Update beneficiary information
- Some additional benefits might be limited outside the U.S.
4. Can universal life insurance be used to finance my child’s college education in the U.S.?
Yes, the cash value in a unit-linked policy can be used to finance college education, with several advantages:
- Withdrawals or loans are tax-free
- They do not affect the eligibility for need-based financial aid (as they are not counted as assets in FAFSA)
- They offer flexible use for any educational purpose
- There are no restrictions on the type of school or program, unlike a 529 plan
Thinksmart Insurance